Differences Between Psychiatrists and Psychologists in Dealing with Mental Disorders

Differences Between Psychiatrists and Psychologists in Dealing with Mental Disorders

In addition to educational background, there are various differences between psychiatrists and psychologists, such as the limits of treatment that can be given to patients. For example, psychiatrists can prescribe medication to treat mental disorders, while psychologists are not allowed to do so.

When someone experiences mental disorders, many recommend seeing a psychologist or psychiatrist. However, did you know that there is a difference between the two? One of them is from the education they take. Psychiatrists undergo medical education and become medical doctors before undergoing specialist mental health training.


What is a Psychiatrist

Psychiatrists are doctors who specialize in mental health and mental disorders. They understand the anatomy of the brain, psychological processes, and environmental factors that affect mental health. Psychiatrists are also able to design and oversee treatment plans that suit the needs of the patient. Not only that, they also play a role in providing education to patients and families.

The way, psychiatrists will help understand about mental conditions specifically, along with ways to manage symptoms that may arise. In this way, patients can have a better quality of life.

Psychiatrists can choose from several types of subspecialties below:

  • Forensic psychiatry if you want to handle legal issues related to mental health.
  • Child and adolescent psychiatry to help overcome mental problems in children and adolescents.
  • Addiction psychiatry that specifically deals with addiction problems.
  • Geriatric psychiatry if you want to help overcome mental health problems in parents or the elderly.
  • Psychosomatic psychiatry to help overcome psychological and emotional problems that cause pain.

Difference between Psychologist and Psychiatrist

There are some fundamental differences between a psychiatrist and a psychologist. These include educational background, how disorders are diagnosed, and the types of mental health problems that can be diagnosed.

  • Educational background
    Psychologists take a bachelor’s degree (S1) in psychology. To open an independent practice and counseling, they must take a master’s program in professional psychology. The majors are divided into several types of psychology, namely:
      • Application of early childhood psychology.
      • Social.
      • Industrial and organizational.
      • Application of health psychology.
      • Application of human resource psychology (HRD).
      • Development.
      • Education.
      • Application of sports psychology.

Unlike psychologists, someone who wants to become a psychiatrist must first complete medical education. After that, they can take a psychiatric specialty. After getting a general                                   practitioner degree, it takes four years to undergo a psychiatric residency. Then, the psychiatrist will have the title of doctor and Sp.KJ (Mental Health Specialist).

  • How to diagnose patients
    A psychologist will invite patients to talk about the problems they are facing. Then invite patients to do a cognitive behavioral test to assess their behavior and emotions. This is done by filling out questionnaires, IQ tests, and neuropsychology. The goal is to see cognitive and memory development. If it gets worse, the psychologist will refer the patient to see a psychiatrist.While a psychiatrist, they know everything about the diagnosis and treatment for every psychological condition of the patient that tends to be complicated. For example, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. This is because, their expertise focuses on chemical imbalances in the human brain. Therefore, psychiatrists can prescribe and provide drug therapy (pharmacotherapy). In addition, they are also qualified to perform brain stimulation therapy, physical examinations, and laboratories. Psychiatrists also have the right to increase the dosage of drug use as an adjustment step.
  • Diagnosed mental health problems
    Psychologists cannot diagnose a person with a mental disorder. However, psychologists can help reduce the intensity of symptoms experienced by patients, with recommendations for a healthier lifestyle.While psychiatrists or mental health specialists, they are able to identify more complex mental disorders. For example, bipolar, anxiety disorders, anorexia nervosa, depression, and schizophrenia.

Conclusion Differences Between Psychologist and Psychiatrist

You can consult a psychologist first if you have mental complaints that interfere with your daily activities. Although they cannot diagnose, psychologists can help provide conclusions. Not only that, psychologists can also help overcome disorders through various approaches. For example, changing lifestyles, sleep patterns, and relaxation techniques that are right for people with problems.

However, if the symptoms that appear are getting worse and even trigger physical symptoms, please visit a psychiatrist. This mental health specialist can diagnose and prescribe medication to relieve symptoms. Both psychologists and psychiatrists have a role in treating mental health problems. The choice depends on the type of treatment you need and your individual preferences.

Conditions for People Who Should See a Psychiatrist

A person should see a psychiatrist when they feel signs of mental health problems. Well, you may need to see a psychiatrist if:

  • Having a severe mental health problem.
  • The mental health condition has been going on for a long time, or keeps coming back.
  • It doesn’t get better with other treatments.
  • You have thoughts of harming yourself or committing suicide.

They can help with mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and other mental disorders. Psychiatrists can also prescribe medications to manage symptoms and provide psychological therapy needed for support and recovery. When someone is going through an emotional crisis, such as a loss or a major problem, a psychiatrist can provide the help needed. In addition, they play a role in improving quality of life by teaching effective coping skills.

By conducting a thorough evaluation, a psychiatrist can provide a proper diagnosis and help the patient’s family through education and support, thus creating a better understanding of mental health. Check yourself first with a general practitioner to make an initial diagnosis related to the health disorder you are experiencing. If the general practitioner finds a problem related to mental health, then he or she will refer you to a psychiatrist.

Tips for Choosing a Psychiatrist

Choosing the best psychiatrist is beneficial to the quality of one’s treatment and mental recovery. Here are some tips for choosing the right one:

  • Consultation with a psychologist
    First of all, you can consult a psychologist first. The psychologist will determine the estimated diagnosis according to the patient’s condition. If severe, he will refer the patient to a psychiatrist.
  • Considering the cost
    The price range for psychiatrists varies, depending on the health facility or clinic you visit. The rate ranges from IDR 150,000 to IDR 450,000 per meeting. However, this can vary by region or health facility.
  • Other important things
    In addition to the two points above, here are some other important things you need to know:
      • Choose a psychiatrist with a complete license and practice permit.
      • Choose a practice location that is closest to your domicile.
      • Make a visit schedule before coming.
      • Agree on the treatment method according to the doctor’s referral.

In some cases, a psychiatrist may prescribe antidepressants to treat the symptoms of depression experienced by the patient. Antidepressants are usually given for several conditions, such as:

      • Symptoms of moderate to severe depression. If symptoms of depression are still mild, the doctor may not recommend the use of antidepressants.
      • Symptoms of depression interfere with daily activities. For example, depression makes sufferers feel unmotivated, hopeless, tired, and even have difficulty doing relatively light activities.
      • If therapy from a psychologist such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) has not brought about significant changes.